Iain Duncan Smith’s Tinker Bell statistics (video)

Regular readers of this blog will know that Iain Duncan Smith is a notorious liar.  There is no point being euphemistic about it because the facts are clear. When confronted about his lies his excuse is that he “believes” that what he has said is true. Because that is how statistics and facts work. Like Tinker Bell, facts can only exist if we really believe in them.

Video © Channel 4 / ITN

IDS lied about his academic record on his CV and he has been lying and misrepresenting statistics for ideological reasons ever since. As a consequence of the welfare changes that he has introduced on the back of this deliberately misleading data people have died but the sanctity of human life does not appear to fall within his ‘belief’ system.

Yesterday’s rebuke is, in fact, the fifth time in the last year alone that Iain Duncan Smith has been caught using dodgy figures.  As well as the items mentioned in the Channel 4 News item, the DWP were criticised as recently as March by the Work and Pensions committee for using unpublished data.

The controversy erupted after top Department for Work and Pensions official Neil Couling tried to defend the government’s Work Programme during a grilling by members of Parliament’s work and pensions committee using unpublished data, which angered MPs as they did not have a chance to properly scrutinize the figures.

Labour member Sheila Gilmore complained to Sir Andrew Dilnot, chair of the UK Statistics Authority, who confirmed that “published official statistics should be referred to in public statements” and that alternative information should be used only in “exceptional circumstances”.

Sir Andrew added: “It is a matter of regret that DWP’s usual practice, which would have ensured compliance with the National Statistician’s guidance, was not followed.”

Labour MP Sheila Gilmore said: “By quoting data that wasn’t publicly available at the time, DWP official Neil Couling made it impossible for my colleagues and I on the Work and Pensions Committee to hold him – and the Ministers to whom he reports – to account. This bad practice must not happen again.”

“This is just the latest statistical foul play from Iain Duncan Smith’s department that I’ve helped to expose over the past year.”

A DWP spokesperson said: “A committee member asked a direct question about the support we provide to the long-term unemployed, and this was answered in good faith with the most up-to-date and useful information to assist the committee in their work.

“DWP has an exceptional record on making data widely available to the general public, and on this occasion we felt it was a priority to provide the relevant information needed at the time, rather than providing a limited and out-of-date response.”

This comes after the UK Statistics Authority earlier this month described DWP Data on sickness and disability benefit employment and support allowance as “potentially misleading” and questioned whether it should be classed a “national statistic”.

The watchdog rebuked the DWP in December for failing to fully explain problems they were experiencing in producing the same data and for not highlighting them soon enough.

Huffington Post 6 March 2014


Related articles

Feel free to add your comments here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s