For every £2 we send to Brussels, we get £1 back and it comes back with a tag on it on what we have to spend it on.
Gisela Stuart, Labour MP and joint head of Vote Leave, speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, April 15.
If we left the EU we would take back control over £19 billion which we
currently hand over every year – about £350m each and every week.
Michael Gove, justice secretary and joint head of Vote Leave, in a speech on April 19.
When assessing whether these two claims by Vote Leave are accurate, it’s worth remembering that the amount the UK pays into and receives from the EU budget varies year by year. Since the 1980s, the UK has also received a rebate to reduce what was deemed an excessive net contribution to the EU because at the time, we were one of the poorest member states.
By claiming that for every £2 we send to Brussels, we get £1 back, Gisela Stuart is in essence arguing that we pay twice as much into the EU budget as we get back. In 2014 and several other years, this is broadly correct.
In an email to The Conversation, Stuart said that her figures were based on figures in the Office for National Statistics’ 2015 Pink Book. That year, the UK’s gross contribution to the EU institutions was £19.1 billion – but EU receipts to the UK amounted to £9.2 billion, “less than half the UK’s gross contribution”.
What’s being counted
But these figures vary from year to year. In 2008, for every £2 the UK contributed, we received about £1.45 back, while in 2013, for every £2 sent we received about £0.74.
There are other complicating factors, mentioned in a recent publication from the Institute for Fiscal Studies. For example, the HM Treasury’s figures include only data that passes through a government agency before reaching the final recipient. So it excludes amounts paid directly to UK recipients, such as universities for research.
Stuart’s observation about money coming to the UK “with a tag on it on what we have to spend it on” is factually correct, but misleading. The money paid out of the EU budget to the member states goes to common EU policies, all of which have been put in place by the member states.
Some money will go to farmers under the Common Agricultural Policy. Other funds will go to Cohesion Policies where, for example, councils have bid successfully for EU funding to support local projects. In Nottingham, for example, EU funding is helping to support the Southern Gateway improvements and the development of the Creative Quarter. Other funds are dispersed for schemes to help job creation, to fund efforts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and so on.
So the “tag” which Stuart refers to simply assigns money to the specific projects the EU is helping to fund in the UK, supporting UK agriculture, or regional development.
But it would be an unusual budget where every person, organisation or country got out what they paid in. The EU budget sees richer EU member states being net contributors, and poorer member states being net recipients. This is a basic principle of re-distributive budgets.
How much per week?
Another figure that is being repeated by Vote Leave campaigners is that the UK sends £350m a week to Brussels.
The way in which the UK’s EU budget rebate works means that the figures that Gove cited are incorrect – even though in his speech he did go on to mention the UK’s rebate. First, our payments are not over £19 billion. Data from HM Treasury confirm the figure to be £18.8 billion. Second, this figure is the highest ever figure, rather than what we contribute “every year”.
Third, the Treasury report shows forecasts from the Office for Budget Responsibility predicting that only in three of the coming six years will our gross contribution be above £19 billion. This is neither a common figure, nor part of a rising trend.
When Gove said “the amount we give to the EU is due to go up – and up – and up”, he is ignoring the detailed evidence to the contrary provided by the Office for Budget Responsibility.
So the £350m figure is simply wrong. Looking at 2014 data, the only year where payments into the EU budget have come close to £19 billion, dividing that figure by 52 weeks gives £350m. Yet the UK’s contributions to the EU Budget are reduced by the rebate. This reduces the figure to £280m – so Gove has exaggerated the actual figure by 25%.
Newsnight video is not part of original article
To watch the clip use the password: imincorrigible
Video © BBC
While Gisela Stuart’s claim that for every £2 put in, the UK gets £1 is partially true, if based on 2014 figures – and the amount does vary year by year. Michael Gove’s reassertion that the UK is paying £350m a week to Brussels omits the rebate the UK receives on its contribution to the EU budget. His assertion that our contribution is going to go up and up and up is contradicted by research from the Office of Budget Responsibility.
Beyond this, such a focus on these numbers fails to put into context the small scale of EU budget transfers, when compared with UK national expenditure. UK total managed expenditure in 2013-14 was £714 billion, and in 2014-15 £732 billion. So the UK’s net contribution to the EU budget is thus less than 1.5% of total government spending.
Peter Holmes, Reader in Economics, University of Sussex
The fact check broadly supports the claim that in the past, the UK has received £1 for every £2 sent to Brussels. But most other analysts have concluded that this – and the claim that the UK sends £350m a week to Brussels – is not the best way to present the figures.
The £19 billion figure used to make these calculations does not take account of the rebate negotiated by Margaret Thatcher in 1984. As the Daily Telegraph put it: “In fact, the rebate is effectively deducted at source, and so not actually sent to the EU at all.” Therefore, the UK actual transfer to Brussels in 2014 was not £19.234 billion but £14.346 billion, according to a House of Commons briefing published in February 2016.
Even if one accepts that the receipts from the EU were around £9.2 billion (which excludes some payments not passing through the Treasury) the UK receives £1 for every £1.55 it actually pays.
- James O’Brien v Brexit’s happy morons shutting down Obama’s free speech (video)
- How Brexit could hurt UK-US trade (The Conversation and video)
- Why pulling out of the EU won’t give Britain complete control over its affairs
- Eurosceptics & UKIP grateful for baby talk distraction as Tory review into EU powers comes up with ‘wrong’ answer
- At last, John Oliver dissects Trump’s dangerous kind of craziness (video)
- John Oliver does piggate (video)
- Bernie Sanders and Jeremy Corbyn: Parallel lines (full length video)
- Jon Stewart to Fox News: Your hypocrisy isn’t a bug in the Fox model, it’s the feature! (video)
- Donald Trump attacks GOP presidential candidates for suckling at the Koch brothers’ money teat (video)
- Louise Mensch – the gaffe prone gift to social media that keeps on giving
- What does sex education in American schools look like? (Jon Oliver) (video)
- Christian conservative parents and the virulent question of sex education in school (video)
- Jon Stewart’s full extended interview with President Barack Obama (video)
- Ricky Gervais’ prediction of the Samuel L Jackson racism incident was spookily accurate
- “This is a terrorist attack” Jon Stewart’s powerful monologue on the Charleston race murders (video)
- The Daily Show with Jon Stewart unpacks the UK general election Part 2 (video)
- James O’Brien’s only making plans for Nigel (or when is toast not toast?) (video)
- Jon Stewart: Hillary Clinton’s donations and diarrhoea (video)
- The ugliness of Fox News and Megyn Kelly’s tsunami of bone headed ignorance (video)
- DOJ investigation proves racism is rampant in Ferguson police department (video)
- Fox News: Ferguson riots result of “racial arsonists” stoking a victim mentality in black America (video)
- How groupthink is transforming (and destroying) our democracy (video)
- Fox News hates the US constitution
- Housing the homeless – yes the answer really is this simple
- How Citigroup wrote the US budget and effectively repealed the Dodd-Frank bank reforms (video)
- Corporations are legally defined as people except when they commit a crime
- Regulation is why the Canadian banking system has had no financial crises in 150 years
- Irrational Debate And A Misinformed Public: Wealth Inequality
- What has Goldman Sachs got in common with the new version of the Monopoly board game?
- Right-wing ideology: “government should never interfere with the free market (except when it suits conservatives)”
- Where Are The British Daily Show And Colbert Report?
- J K Rowling knows that fair tax is the price we pay for civilisation
- RNC claim thirty-five thousand ‘possible’ cases of voter fraud justifies their racist reforms but they’re wrong (again)
- Biased US supreme court strengthens wealthy donors’ influence on political parties
- Supreme Court declares racism is dead in America…..but they forgot to tell Donald Sterling and Cliven Bundy…
- Thomas Piketty – Why we need a global wealth tax
- Benghazi! Benghazi! Benghazi! Stephen Colbert and Jon Stewart on the 60 minutes gaff
- If you don’t like gays, don’t run a bed and breakfast
- The end of net neutrality is why everything that you enjoy on the internet is about to cost you more
- NRA Conference Speakers Message To America: Fear Everything And Everyone
- The 24 hour news cycle gives us all heat but very little light
- Capitalism: serving God and Mammon?
- If you thought that 1,700 applications for 8 coffee shop jobs was bad you ain’t seen nothing yet!(imincorrigible.wordpress.com)
- How banks have hoodwinked you over high frequency trading
- Gun Control Works and the Australian Experience Proves It
- Investment Banks & Bankers: Too Big (Headed) To Jail
- “Murdoch’s World” and praising fox like you should! (imincorrigible.wordpress.com)
- Outfoxed: Rupert Murdoch’s War on Journalism